- A mother arrived at school to find her kindergartner huddled under a table in the school office scared to death and screaming. The mom had never seen her daughter behave like this before. Police tried to handcuff the girl whose tiny wrists were too slim for the cuffs. At the hospital she was labeled with bipolar disorder, ADHD and oppositional defiant disorder and following her drug treatment for these “disorders” got Baker Acted again from school.
- A fourth-grader was committed right off the school bus while on his way home. His mom said that what her son told her happened on the bus and what the bus cameras showed was different than what the school police told her. She had to leave her son at the psychiatric hospital crying and begging for her to stay with him. The boy had never slept away from home before. After release the boy told about his hospital stay where he met a girl who cut patterns into her skin with a knife, a boy addicted to pills, and a boy wearing a prison jumpsuit. And he spent his first night away from his home with a roommate who punched him in the face. The boy also recalls sitting handcuffed in the hot police car while his classmates watched him from the windows of the school bus.
Baker Acting NOT Discipline?
School officials are quick to point out that such treatment under the Baker Act is not discipline.
How could a grade school or kindergartner child not feel he was being disciplined if he was forcibly handcuffed, strapped in a police car and driven away to a psychiatric facility while his peers and teachers watched the car drive away?
In Flagler County, FL in 2014 the school board discussed the rise of Baker Act incidents involving elementary school age kids and attempted to diffuse the anger parents were feeling.
The presentation was made by Katrina Townsend, the district’s director of student services who said, “I have also sat on both sides of the table at Halifax (the psychiatric ward at Halifax Hospital in Daytona Beach) as the parent of a patient, and as a representative of you, the school board, so I like to think I knew a little bit about it as well. And having gone through the process as a parent, I feel confident in the services that they provide to us.”
Is she biased favorably in terms of Baker Acting kids in her role of as director of student services based on her faith in the psychiatric system into which she Baker Acted her own child
Townsend went onto to say, “A Baker Act is absolutely not a discipline consequence.”
She offered this analogy between Baker Acts and an asthma attack. “Mental health, just like asthma can have a critical issue or an event that requires emergency care and in mental health, that emergency care is often a Baker Act. As with a student with asthma, we would not identify that a student was having a crisis and send them home to sort it out. We would transport them for emergency care. So once I heard that analogy it kind of helped me wrap my head a round it a little bit.”
However, School Board member Colleen Conklin did not buy this idea and sided with the outraged parents.
Conklin stated, “A Baker Acting of a child is traumatically different than what was just described in the analogy of an asthma attack. The reason that you have the media and that you have some become so outraged, if you will, is because it goes against all of our senses, at the thought of a child receiving help by being placed in either handcuffs or put in the back of a patrol car. That is not dealing in the same manner as you do with somebody who has an asthma attack… That to me exacerbates the situation and is more traumatizing to a child.”
There are known alternatives for helping kids that avoid the dangerous mental and physical harm caused by psychiatric drugs.
Parents, school administrators and police in Florida could be educated to learn the truth about the drugs currently given to children and what the workable alternatives are. Then we could end the disgraceful Baker Acting of kids from their Florida classrooms.
As one who has had a family member “Baker Acted”, I will say that there seems to be some simple changes that could be made to alleviate the child’s distress. First off, the person at the school needs to clearly inform the student that they are not in trouble, but that need to see a doctor. AND the school needs to notify the parents immediately. Also, instead of a squad car showing up, why not an unmarked police car with no lights or sirens, and instead of a uniformed police officer, why not have the officer dressed in business casual who can still show credentials to the school staff for the pick up? And maybe also, taking the child from the school and into the car during class time, or when students are elsewhere to alleviate the embarrassment and “optics” of the situation? Using some good sense could go a long way in calming the student and the parents.
And yes, the Baker Act should be amended so that parents have more control over when their child is committed and to give them more control during the hold. I understand the reason for the act, but good sense needs to prevail in the amending of the law and the carrying out of the law. More awareness needs to be brought to the law and the down-sides of enforcing this on children and adults alike.
Thank you for your comment. That children as young as 5 years old are being Baker Acted without parental knowledge or consent is a gross violation of civil and parental rights. It is our goal to protect the children of this state and restore parental rights.
This is ridiculous someone needs to do something.